What to Look for When Hiring a Virtual Assistant (Red Flags & Green Flags)
- Keizy Ola Cecillano
- Nov 20, 2025
- 6 min read
Hiring a virtual assistant can be a game-changer for your business or a costly mistake.
The right VA frees up your time, handles tasks professionally, and helps you grow. The wrong VA creates more work, misses deadlines, and leaves you frustrated.
So how do you find the right fit? What should you look for and what should you avoid?
In this guide, we’ll walk you through the red flags and green flags to watch for when hiring a virtual assistant, so you can make a confident, informed decision.
Why Hiring the Right VA Matters
A great VA is more than just an extra pair of hands. They:
Save you time by handling tasks efficiently
Reduce stress by taking work off your plate
Improve quality by bringing specialized skills
Enable growth by freeing you to focus on strategy
A bad VA, on the other hand:
Wastes your time with poor communication and mistakes
Increases stress by requiring constant oversight
Damages your reputation with sloppy work
Costs you money with missed deadlines and lost opportunities
The difference between a great VA and a bad one can make or break your business. Here’s how to spot the difference.
Green Flags: What to Look For in a Great VA
✅ 1. Clear, Professional Communication
What to look for:
Responds promptly (within 24 hours)
Writes clearly and professionally
Asks clarifying questions before starting work
Proactively updates you on progress
Why it matters: Communication is the foundation of remote work. If a VA can’t communicate well during the hiring process, it won’t improve once they’re working for you.
Test it: Pay attention to how they respond to your initial inquiry. Are they professional? Do they ask good questions? Do they follow up?
✅ 2. Relevant Experience and Specialized Skills
What to look for:
- Experience in your industry or with similar clients
- Specialized skills (social media, bookkeeping, project management, etc.)
- Portfolio or examples of past work
- References or testimonials from previous clients
Why it matters: A VA with relevant experience requires less training and delivers better results faster.
Test it: Ask for examples of similar projects they’ve completed. Request references and actually call them.
✅ 3. Proactive Problem-Solving
What to look for:
Anticipates challenges and suggests solutions
Takes initiative without needing constant direction
Offers ideas for improvement
Doesn’t just follow instructions, thinks strategically
Why it matters: A proactive VA becomes a true partner, not just a task-taker. They help you improve processes and grow your business.
Test it: During the interview, present a hypothetical challenge and ask how they’d handle it. Do they think critically or just wait for instructions?
✅ 4. Reliable and Accountable
What to look for:
Meets deadlines consistently
Takes ownership of mistakes and fixes them
Uses project management tools to track tasks
Provides regular updates without needing to be asked
Why it matters: Reliability is non-negotiable. If you can’t trust your VA to follow through, you’ll spend more time managing them than they save you.
Test it: Start with a small, time-sensitive project. Do they deliver on time? Do they communicate if there’s a delay?
✅ 5. Understands Your Business and Goals
What to look for:
Asks about your business, audience, and goals
Tailors their approach to your needs
Shows genuine interest in your success
Aligns their work with your vision
Why it matters: A VA who understands your business delivers better results because they see the bigger picture, not just individual tasks.
Test it: During the interview, ask them to explain how they’d approach a key task for your business. Do they ask clarifying questions? Do they think strategically?
✅ 6. Uses the Right Tools and Systems
What to look for:
Familiar with tools you already use (Asana, Trello, Slack, Google Workspace, etc.)
Willing to learn new tools quickly
Suggests tools or systems to improve efficiency
Comfortable with technology and troubleshooting
Why it matters: A tech-savvy VA integrates seamlessly into your workflow and can help you optimize processes.
Test it: Ask what tools they use for project management, communication, and task tracking. Are they up-to-date with current platforms?
✅ 7. Transparent Pricing and Contracts
What to look for:
Clear, upfront pricing with no hidden fees
Flexible contracts (monthly, not locked into long-term commitments)
Transparent about what’s included and what costs extra
Willing to adjust scope as your needs change
Why it matters: Surprises in pricing or contract terms create frustration and mistrust. Transparency builds confidence.
Test it: Ask for a detailed breakdown of costs and what’s included. Are they clear and upfront, or vague and evasive?
Red Flags: Warning Signs to Avoid
1. Poor Communication or Slow Response Times
Warning signs:
Takes days to respond to emails or messages
Vague or unclear answers
Doesn’t ask clarifying questions
Misses scheduled calls or meetings
Why it’s a problem: If communication is poor before you hire them, it will only get worse. You’ll waste time chasing updates and clarifying mistakes.
What to do: Move on. Communication is non-negotiable.
2. No Relevant Experience or Portfolio
Warning signs:
Can’t provide examples of past work
No references or testimonials
Claims to “do everything” without specialization
Overpromises results without evidence
Why it’s a problem: Without proven experience, you’re gambling on their ability to deliver. You’ll spend time training them, and they may still underperform.
What to do: Ask for specific examples and references. If they can’t provide them, keep looking.
3. Unwilling to Start with a Trial or Small Project
Warning signs:
Insists on long-term contracts upfront
Won’t agree to a trial period or test project
Pressures you to commit immediately
Refuses to provide a money-back guarantee or flexibility
Why it’s a problem: A VA who won’t do a trial likely knows they can’t deliver. Reputable VAs are confident in their work and willing to prove themselves.
What to do: Insist on a trial period or small project before committing long-term.
4. Lacks Accountability or Blames Others
Warning signs:
Makes excuses for missed deadlines
Blames clients, tools, or circumstances for poor results
Doesn’t take ownership of mistakes
Defensive when given feedback
Why it’s a problem: A VA who can’t take responsibility will create more problems than they solve. You’ll spend time managing their excuses instead of growing your business.
What to do: Pay attention to how they talk about past clients. Do they take ownership, or do they blame others?
5. Offers Unrealistically Low Prices
Warning signs:
Charges far below market rates (e.g., $5/hour)
Promises “unlimited” work for a flat fee
No clear scope or boundaries
Why it’s a problem: You get what you pay for. Extremely low prices often mean poor quality, lack of experience, or unrealistic expectations.
What to do: Be wary of prices that seem too good to be true. Quality VAs charge fair rates for their expertise.
6. No Systems or Project Management Tools
Warning signs:
Doesn’t use project management tools (Asana, Trello, ClickUp, etc.)
Relies only on email for communication
No process for tracking tasks or deadlines
Can’t provide progress updates
Why it’s a problem: Without systems, work becomes chaotic. You’ll waste time chasing updates and clarifying what’s been done.
What to do: Ask what tools they use. If they don’t have a system, they’re not a professional VA.
7. Vague or Unclear About Availability
Warning signs:
Won’t commit to specific working hours
Unclear about time zone or availability
Takes on too many clients and is constantly “busy”
Doesn’t respond during agreed-upon working hours
Why it’s a problem: If you can’t rely on them to be available when needed, they’re not a good fit for your business.
What to do: Clarify availability and working hours upfront. If they’re vague, move on.
How to Vet a VA: The 5-Step Process
Follow this process to ensure you hire the right VA:
Step 1: Define Your Needs
List the tasks you want to delegate
Identify required skills and experience
Determine your budget and timeline
Step 2: Review Portfolios and References
Ask for examples of similar work
Contact references and ask about reliability, communication, and quality
Step 3: Conduct a Video Interview
Assess communication skills and professionalism
Ask about their process, tools, and experience
Present a hypothetical challenge and see how they respond
Step 4: Start with a Trial Project
Assign a small, time-sensitive task
Evaluate quality, communication, and timeliness
Provide feedback and see how they respond
Step 5: Establish Clear Expectations
Set clear goals, deadlines, and communication protocols
Use project management tools to track progress
Schedule regular check-ins
The Virtually Yours Difference: Why We’re the Green Flag Choice
At Virtually Yours, we’ve built our agency around the green flags that matter most:
✅Team-based approach: You get a dedicated team (not just one person), so you’re never left without support.
✅Vetted, experienced VAs: We carefully match you with VAs who have relevant experience and proven skills.
✅Clear communication: Regular check-ins, project management tools, and proactive updates.
✅Transparent pricing: No hidden fees. Flexible packages ($397-$2,797/month).
✅Fast onboarding: Get started in 3-5 days.
✅Accountability: We take ownership of results and continuously improve.
Ready to Hire the Right VA?
Don’t settle for a VA who creates more work than they solve. At Virtually Yours, we make hiring easy, reliable, and stress-free.
Fill out our application and let’s match you with a dedicated team who understands your business and delivers results.
About Virtually Yours
We’re a virtual assistant agency serving small businesses, startups, churches, and ministries worldwide. Our team-based approach means you get the support you need, when you need it, without the risk of hiring the wrong person.
Comments